Quote | piotrfr posted on Dec 27 2013 01:08 pm UTC
[quote name='Switcher7' date='Dec 27 2013 11:46 am UTC']
so just keep calm piotr, it's christmas if you think my decision were wrong there you go, but I wont change them again I'm sorry
If you really feel to do.something, maybe created a thread were we have a actual collection of all rules for competiton and what happens if you dont follow them
In this way: Merry christmas and a happy new year[/quote]
I'm perfectly calm.
You just confirm, as a referee, that you don't give a shit about your own rule :
"all registrants have 74 hours (until 20:00 GMT Monday 23rd) to attack EVERY other registrant ONCE EACH."
You don't want to "punish" the 3 players, so you punish the defender, really fair as you say.
So after you brok your own rule you invent a new one, after the end of the contest, without any discussion about it:
- If an attacker don't attack a registrant, it's a defeat with 2 potions (why ? cause I say it.... nice discussion)
And then you still don't count all my potions cause if it is this way I have 14 potions consumed and not 10.
After that you demote Zhoutai with no word for him, and you reward one rule-breaker (not intentionnaly but still)....
Am I furious about it ? no.
Am I fine with it ? certainly not.
When we take time and reflexion to build 2 times a castle, attack all other registrants, follow the uneasy new rules, follow the contest topic, give comments and explanations, all of that in christmas time..... that's not for having a final diktat of "referee" which decide alone of the winner (in 2 times).
That was my last contest with you as "referee", since you don't respect your own rules you can't be trusted.
Merry christmas and a happy new year.
Normally I would punish people for not attacking someone else you're right, BUT IN THE CURRENT CASE PEOPLE WEREN T ABLE TO ATTACKE BY A INGAME ISSUE, so why should I punish anyone because of a bug by the game? So I went for a solution which semeed to be fair for all sides, so calm down piotr take your seat and fix any possible problems in your up coming competitions
For zhoutai I'm sorry but it was a fault by my side hope he's not to mad about it. But he didn't attacked you either Piotr ! He actually came up with the idea of 2 potions and a win, I thought about it and used that decision for the problem for all cases so actually it's fair.
And again it's the first time that people weren't able to attack because of an ingame problem, so we couldn't suggest about this this problems before the competition has started, by the way the competitions were made for fun and not for discussions :3