Logo_beta-f64e62b463c7f6f8b46ce398daa62d8d Mighty Quest for Epic Loot

Post Icon Gladiator Competition -Hardcore- December 20th

Displaying posts 151-159 of 159

Profile Picture

Spocy

Newbie

533 Posts

Joined 2013-06-20

December 27, 2013 11:53 (4 months ago)

Congratulations to all winners, I do think it is rather sad that there is so much grief going on however.
It was a new kind of competition never did before, it is only to be expected that some rules may in the end seem to not be the best possible. Still its a free to join competition for which you can get free prices, so what if you missed out because a rule for this competition might not have been best for its purpose, it was good fun right?

Hell I would join these competitions without prices just as easily. It is about having fun as high level players in my opinion. Why else would I join this competition with my knight knowing full well that it would be far easier with my archer. (I just wish I had more time to join more competitions lol :P )

It is good to discuss certain rules for future competitions of this kind, but lets not argue about the effects on this competitions, what's done is done and it should not be a big deal regardless.


Profile Picture
Legit Fan

piotrfr

Newbie

628 Posts

Joined 2013-04-19

December 27, 2013 13:08 (4 months ago)

Quote | Switcher7 posted on Dec 27 2013 11:46 am UTC

so just keep calm piotr, it's christmas if you think my decision were wrong there you go, but I wont change them again I'm sorry

If you really feel to do.something, maybe created a thread were we have a actual collection of all rules for competiton and what happens if you dont follow them

In this way: Merry christmas and a happy new year

I'm perfectly calm.

You just confirm, as a referee, that you don't give a shit about your own rule :

"all registrants have 74 hours (until 20:00 GMT Monday 23rd) to attack EVERY other registrant ONCE EACH."

You don't want to "punish" the 3 players, so you punish the defender, really fair as you say.

So after you brok your own rule you invent a new one, after the end of the contest, without any discussion about it:

  • If an attacker don't attack a registrant, it's a defeat with 2 potions (why ? cause I say it.... nice discussion)

And then you still don't count all my potions cause if it is this way I have 14 potions consumed and not 10.

After that you demote Zhoutai with no word for him, and you reward one rule-breaker (not intentionnaly but still)....

Am I furious about it ? no.

Am I fine with it ? certainly not.

When we take time and reflexion to build 2 times a castle, attack all other registrants, follow the uneasy new rules, follow the contest topic, give comments and explanations, all of that in christmas time..... that's not for having a final diktat of "referee" which decide alone of the winner (in 2 times).

That was my last contest with you as "referee", since you don't respect your own rules you can't be trusted.

Merry christmas and a happy new year.


Profile Picture
High Roller

UKAzzer

Newbie

456 Posts

Joined 2013-06-20

December 27, 2013 13:34 (4 months ago)

It's not like you to suck the fun out of a competition with your brandishing of a rulebook, Piotr... :)


Profile Picture

Deli89

Newbie

94 Posts

Joined 2013-11-17

December 27, 2013 14:25 (4 months ago)

Piotr, i know what u mean.

But you already created some competitions yourself, and you know that you cant always take every rule 100%.

Why should we/he/you punish anyone, who just CANT attack someone cause of gamemechanics?
Ofcourse, there had to be a rule from the beginning, what happens if someone cant attack anyone (like the defender gets the win + 2potions used) .... That was his fault...

But in some way we are doing these competition to find out new/every rule. To make competitions easier and better.
So let us do a own "Thread/Wiki" for our competitions, with all rules for every style of competition in it?

And yes, he needs to change your potions in the results.....

happy new year to everyone!

last edited: December 27, 2013 14:26 (4 months ago)

Profile Picture
Chunk of Change

Switcher7

Newbie

327 Posts

Joined 2013-06-11

December 27, 2013 17:05 (4 months ago)

Quote | piotrfr posted on Dec 27 2013 01:08 pm UTC

[quote name='Switcher7' date='Dec 27 2013 11:46 am UTC'] so just keep calm piotr, it's christmas if you think my decision were wrong there you go, but I wont change them again I'm sorry

If you really feel to do.something, maybe created a thread were we have a actual collection of all rules for competiton and what happens if you dont follow them

In this way: Merry christmas and a happy new year[/quote]

I'm perfectly calm.

You just confirm, as a referee, that you don't give a shit about your own rule :

"all registrants have 74 hours (until 20:00 GMT Monday 23rd) to attack EVERY other registrant ONCE EACH."

You don't want to "punish" the 3 players, so you punish the defender, really fair as you say.

So after you brok your own rule you invent a new one, after the end of the contest, without any discussion about it:

  • If an attacker don't attack a registrant, it's a defeat with 2 potions (why ? cause I say it.... nice discussion)

And then you still don't count all my potions cause if it is this way I have 14 potions consumed and not 10.

After that you demote Zhoutai with no word for him, and you reward one rule-breaker (not intentionnaly but still)....

Am I furious about it ? no.

Am I fine with it ? certainly not.

When we take time and reflexion to build 2 times a castle, attack all other registrants, follow the uneasy new rules, follow the contest topic, give comments and explanations, all of that in christmas time..... that's not for having a final diktat of "referee" which decide alone of the winner (in 2 times).

That was my last contest with you as "referee", since you don't respect your own rules you can't be trusted.

Merry christmas and a happy new year.

Normally I would punish people for not attacking someone else you're right, BUT IN THE CURRENT CASE PEOPLE WEREN T ABLE TO ATTACKE BY A INGAME ISSUE, so why should I punish anyone because of a bug by the game? So I went for a solution which semeed to be fair for all sides, so calm down piotr take your seat and fix any possible problems in your up coming competitions

And for gods seek I'll fix the sheet Oo

For zhoutai I'm sorry but it was a fault by my side hope he's not to mad about it. But he didn't attacked you either Piotr ! He actually came up with the idea of 2 potions and a win, I thought about it and used that decision for the problem for all cases so actually it's fair.

And again it's the first time that people weren't able to attack because of an ingame problem, so we couldn't suggest about this this problems before the competition has started, by the way the competitions were made for fun and not for discussions :3


Profile Picture

guest-XyoDpOGlk

Ambassador

519 Posts

Joined 2013-11-02

December 27, 2013 23:26 (4 months ago)

I'm curious if the people who didn't attack piotrfr checked there battlelogs and then attacked though there.

Because I couldn't attack piotrfr (If I had left it at that I could of won with 2 pots) but then piotrfr posted on the thread how to attack him in 3 ways and I followed the instructions(Attacked though my battlelog) then died in his castle only if i had of ignored that post i could of won, silly me for trying :P (I thought it would of counted my as a loss only reason I figured out how to attack)

I still don't understand why killing someone with 0 potions used is the lowest of low and treated as a useless castle. (It's better to have someone not attack or have someone beat 99% of your castle then die then it is to kill them easily in the first room)

But besides all the rablegarble rule stuff on the thread I found it a fun competition and the only reason I entered this one and not the other competitions is because this one looked fun and it was. (And it's good practice for free creation mode)
Hope there is more interesting unique competitions like this or something else in the future. (Because the standard make a normal castle spamming the flavor of the month minion/trap is boring to me)

Also how do i claim my reward?

last edited: December 27, 2013 23:38 (4 months ago)

Profile Picture

guest-svD2GgB0

Ambassador

1,919 Posts

Joined 2013-08-31

December 28, 2013 00:12 (4 months ago)

Quote | guest-XyoDpOGl posted on Dec 27 2013 12:52 am UTC

So if someone doesn't attack=Win+2 potions Killing someone first room=Win+0potions.

It's better to have someone not attack then it is to have a really well made castle that kills someone in the first room before they can use a potion?

[quote name='guest-svD2GgB0' date='Dec 26 2013 07:38 pm UTC'] Firstly he died and his death had nothing to do with him hitting that trap.

2nd.) He broke the rule and left the boss room if you really want to get picky about it.

3rd) The trap was behind 1 of my mine's at the very end of my Castle past every monster just before the gate. I didn't know that I hadn't taken it out.

And lastly I really don't care too much about his violation of the rule.... just thinking it's pretty silly to try to beg 1 star when you broke a rule in the first place. ;)[/quote] Having a trap in castle=Instant DQ you technically already lost before I did anything in the castle. Most importantly I'm pretty sure I only went near the edge of the room(because of the faded floor near entrance) then remembered I couldn't leave I never actually left the room. You can record the replay and upload it if you are 100% certain I left, I have nothing to hide I'm almost 100% certain i didn't leave(Only went to leave and remebered I couldn't before actually leaving) I got DQ'd for missing 1 hidden baddog (In deliqq's castle and he won the "Blood and sand" because of it) but it had no effect my attack run at all (I like one shot the room really easily with a volley if i remember correctly and there was just one baddog hiding and beat his castle but I still got DQ'd for that attack)

So I decided to count my attack on your castle as a DQ because you had a trap (It didn't effect anything, Just like missing one bad dog didn't miss anything. But a rules a rule) I should of won your castle anyway imo (If i had left your room would of been easy)

Disqualify me or don't it doesn't really matter to me.

Neither of us broke the rule on purpose it was an accident. Get over yourself and step down from your high horse....

Whether you stepped 1 foot on the line or didn't I don't really care. I'm not going to make a recording to try to get you disqualified for something so stupid as going oops I was supposed to fight in this room. You punished yourself enough by walking into the Jimbo and dieing on the easiest room in the Castle.

last edited: December 28, 2013 00:13 (4 months ago)

Profile Picture

guest-svD2GgB0

Ambassador

1,919 Posts

Joined 2013-08-31

December 28, 2013 00:14 (4 months ago)

Quote | guest-XyoDpOGl posted on Dec 27 2013 11:26 pm UTC

Also how do i claim my reward?

You will have to wait till the MQ team come's back from Holiday's then probably a few days after for them to hand it out. I think typically it's been about 4 days after the results are final give or take a day.

last edited: December 28, 2013 00:14 (4 months ago)

Profile Picture

guest-XyoDpOGlk

Ambassador

519 Posts

Joined 2013-11-02

December 28, 2013 00:33 (4 months ago)

Quote | guest-svD2GgB0 posted on Dec 28 2013 12:14 am UTC

[quote name='guest-XyoDpOGl' date='Dec 27 2013 11:26 pm UTC']
Also how do i claim my reward?[/quote]

You will have to wait till the MQ team come's back from Holiday's then probably a few days after for them to hand it out. I think typically it's been about 4 days after the results are final give or take a day.

k cool.

I don't get why you saying things like "Get over yourself" "Get down from your high horse" though?!?!?!? I said it was nothing personal in my first post.

You do realize why I DQ'd you right? (Look at it from my perspective before you accuse me of been on high horses)

-I had 4 wins
-Switcher has 3 wins.
-I had won the competition
-Deliqq DQ'd me on one of his attacks (For missing 1 trivial bad dog which would have made no difference at all)
-I'm now on 3 wins
-I'm now tied with switcher
-I don't know how the tie breaker works so I could of lost.
-I decide to DQ you and Ocylix to bring me back to first place. (Not any other reason)

-Lost my first place to trivial DQ's
-Gained my first place back with trivial DQ's

Yea I made you lose but as you say "Disqualify me or don't it doesn't really matter to me." Then why are you so upset that you would insult me? Because I DQ'd you for a trivial matter? Look at the hole picture instead of that isolated incident, I got DQ'd for a trivial matter so i DQ'd you for a trivial matter, Not out of spite not out of hatred for you or deliqq nothing to do with you or anyone or anything I just wanted my 1st place spot back (Since I lost it to a trivial DQ's I don't see the problem with gaining it back with trivial DQ's)

last edited: December 28, 2013 00:36 (4 months ago)

Displaying posts 151-159 of 159

Please log in to reply.